Guide / Research-based
KOYUDO FU-3 vs FU-4: Goat Hair, Synthetic Bristles and Foundation Brush Choice
Start with what you need from a brush, rather than choosing by the words “liquid” or “mineral.” FU-3 has goat hair; FU-4 has synthetic PBT bristles. That difference can settle a material preference, but it cannot tell you which will give a better finish with your foundation.
This is a research-based buying guide to the two standard single brushes. We have not used or comparatively tested them. The aim is to help you narrow the choice, keep your current tool, or wait for information that matters to you.
Step 1 — Do you need another brush?
Name the problem you want to solve. Are you avoiding animal-hair bristles, specifically looking for goat hair, or replacing a tool that no longer suits your routine?
If your current brush or sponge already works with your makeup, buying neither is a reasonable outcome. The sources reviewed here do not establish that either FU-3 or FU-4 will improve your results. You do not need both simply to cover two foundation categories.
If you have a clear requirement, use it as the first filter below.
Step 2 — What is your bristle-material requirement?
If avoiding animal-hair bristles is essential, exclude FU-3. KOYUDO lists its hair as 白尖 and places it in the goat-hair category. CDJapan describes the material as Goat Hakutotsuho. Those are source-specific descriptions of the hair, not certifications of quality or sourcing. KOYUDO FU-3, goat-hair category, CDJapan FU-3 details.
FU-4 is the candidate to consider for synthetic bristles: KOYUDO specifies PBT and includes it under 人工毛, its synthetic-hair category. If you require vegan certification covering the complete brush and all its components, pause here. The bristle specification does not establish that wider assurance. KOYUDO FU-4, synthetic-hair category.
Conversely, if you specifically want goat hair, FU-3 meets that stated material preference and FU-4 does not. We have not established how either will feel on your skin.
Step 3 — What does the source actually say about foundation use?
KOYUDO names FU-3 a liquid brush and FU-4 a mineral brush. CDJapan explicitly describes FU-4 for both liquid and mineral foundation. Do not eliminate FU-4 from a liquid-foundation shortlist because of its name, or assume these brushes form an exclusive “liquid versus mineral” pair. FU-3 manufacturer name, FU-4 manufacturer name, FU-4 retailer use description.
For mineral foundation, FU-4's name and retailer description support considering it. They do not establish that FU-3 cannot be used with mineral foundation. Nor does broad fu-pa series language about foundation and loose powder validate either brush for your exact formula.
If compatibility with a particular foundation is non-negotiable, identify the formula and brush model and seek applicable guidance before ordering. This research does not resolve formulation, amount or technique-specific suitability.
Step 4 — How do shape and care affect your choice?
KOYUDO specifies round-flat (丸平) for FU-3 and flat (フラット) for FU-4. Both are listed at 105 mm overall, with 27 mm of exposed bristles: 出穂 refers to the bristle length, not the handle. These are maker-listed dimensions, not our measurements. Equal lengths do not establish equal contact area or feel; the shape labels do not prove coverage, evenness or reduced irritation. FU-3 specifications, FU-4 specifications.
Then consider whether you want another tool to maintain. KOYUDO's general care guidance distinguishes powder use from liquid/cream use. It describes gentle residue removal, warns against hard rubbing, and calls for rinsing, reshaping and shade drying after washing, with care around direct sunlight and hair-dryer heat. These are general instructions, not a validated FU-3 or FU-4 cleaning schedule or an exact-model approved-cleanser list. Do not assume PBT automatically means less maintenance. KOYUDO general brush care.
Use this table to decide what to investigate next. It is a decision aid, not a performance ranking.
| Reader's requirement | What the evidence helps you consider | What still needs checking |
|---|---|---|
| Avoiding animal-hair bristles | Exclude goat-hair FU-3; consider PBT FU-4 for its bristle material. | Whole-product assurances, if required; suitability for your makeup and routine. |
| Specifically wanting goat hair | Consider FU-3 on its stated material; FU-4 does not meet that preference. | Feel, finish and skin compatibility remain untested here. |
| Planning to use liquid foundation | FU-3 has the maker's liquid-brush name; FU-4 also has retailer support for liquid use. | Compatibility with your particular formula; do not choose by name alone. |
| Planning to use mineral foundation | FU-4's maker name and retailer use description support considering it. | Formula-specific suitability and results; this is not evidence that FU-3 is unusable. |
| Requiring proven skin compatibility, performance or complete vegan certification | The available specifications do not settle these requirements. | Obtain evidence that covers the exact requirement, or postpone the purchase. |
| Already having a suitable brush, or wanting to avoid extra maintenance | Keep the current tool; buying neither avoids adding a care routine. | Whether there is a genuine unmet need before reconsidering. |
The specifications and stated uses are documentary evidence. Excluding, considering or postponing a purchase is our conditional editorial interpretation. Unresolved points are not proof that a brush is unsuitable.
Step 5 — Is this the exact item, and is buying practical?
Check the model, catalog number and hair description together:
- FU-3 / fu-pa02: CDJapan NEOKUD-1369, goat hair.
- FU-4 / fu-pa03: CDJapan NEOKUD-1040, PBT.
Do not substitute a CB or older limited-edition listing based on a shared fu-pa name. For the full specifications, retailer-listed JANs, variant boundaries and care caveats, read the KOYUDO FU-3 Product Profile or KOYUDO FU-4 Product Profile.
A photograph is not a promise of an exact handle logo. CDJapan's FU-3 notice describes a difference between the page image and the actual logo. Its FU-4 notice describes a stock transition to a new logo and says buyers cannot select one. We have not inspected a shipped unit. If a particular marking is essential, resolve that before paying. FU-3 notice, FU-4 notice.
Before ordering, check the current price, availability, dispatch estimate, destination-specific shipping and total cost, import conditions, and the seller's return terms, including how it treats minor imperfections. Packaging and included extras are unverified here. The available evidence also does not establish the exact unit's country of manufacture or individual Kumano-brush certification.
Return to your starting requirement: consider FU-3 for a goat-hair preference, consider FU-4 for synthetic bristles, keep your present tool if it already works, or wait if a required compatibility, certification or purchase detail remains unresolved. Nothing in this comparison requires choosing a winner before you have the evidence you need.
